Monday, 11 November, 14:00 CET

Experts, citizens, and how they can work together – the epistemic argument for social justice

The relation between experts and citizens is often portrayed as one of conflict; expertocracy and democracy are seen as mutually exclusive. In this talk, I suggest a model that moves beyond this antagonism, towards a model of partnership that allows the development of mutual trust, but not blind trust. Key for this model is the basic insight that all citizens are, in some sense, experts, and all are, in many areas, lay people. As lay people and as experts, they have democratic responsibilities to make this partnership functional. However, this model is most likely to function in a society in which there can be mutual trust between different social group – which leads to an epistemic argument for social justice in the sense of more socio-economic equality and mutual contact between citizens.  

Lisa Herzog works at the intersection of political philosophy and economic thought. She has been held her position at the Faculty of Philosophy of the University of Groningen since 2019; since 2021 she is the Directer of the Center for Philosophy, Politics and Economics, and since January 2023, Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy.
She holds a master (Diplom) in economics from LMU Munich, and an M.St. in Philosophy and D.Phil. in Political Theory from the University of Oxford, where she was a Rhodes Scholar. She has worked at, or visited, the universities of St. Gallen (CH), Leuven (BE), Frankfurt/Main (D), Utrecht (NL), and Stanford (US), and has held fellowships of Wissen-schaftskolleg zu Berlin and Hamburg Institute for Advanced Study.  
Herzog has published on the philosophical dimensions of markets, liberalism and social justice, ethics in organizations, and political epistemology. She is a co-editor of the interdisciplinary journal Review of Social Economy. Her latest monograph is Citizen Knowledge. Markets, Experts, and the Infrastructure of Democracy. The current focus of her work are economic democracy and the philosophy of work.

The lecture takes place on site at ITAS (Karlstraße 11, Kalrsruhe) and will be broadcast via Zoom. Please contact Meike Hebich for the Zoom access if you are interested to participate. The language of the event is English.

Monday, 15 July, 14:00

Experts, citizens, and how they can work together – the epistemic argument for social justice

The relation between experts and citizens is often portrayed as one of conflict; expertocracy and democracy are seen as mutually exclusive. In this talk, I suggest a model that moves beyond this antagonism, towards a model of partnership that allows the development of mu-tual trust, but not blind trust. Key for this model is the basic insight that all citizens are, in some sense, experts, and all are, in many areas, lay people. As lay people and as experts, they have democratic responsibilities to make this partnership functional. However, this model is most likely to function in a society in which there can be mutual trust between dif-ferent social group – which leads to an epistemic argument for social justice in the sense of more socio-economic equality and mutual contact between citizens.  

Lisa Herzog works at the intersection of political philosophy and economic thought. She has been held her position at the Faculty of Philosophy of the University of Groningen since 2019; since 2021 she is the Directer of the Center for Philosophy, Politics and Economics, and since January 2023, Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy.
She holds a master (Diplom) in economics from LMU Munich, and an M.St. in Philosophy and D.Phil. in Political Theory from the University of Oxford, where she was a Rhodes Scholar. She has worked at, or visited, the universities of St. Gallen (CH), Leuven (BE), Frankfurt/Main (D), Utrecht (NL), and Stanford (US), and has held fellowships of Wissen-schaftskolleg zu Berlin and Hamburg Institute for Advanced Study.  
Herzog has published on the philosophical dimensions of markets, liberalism and social jus-tice, ethics in organizations, and political epistemology. She is a co-editor of the interdiscipli-nary journal Review of Social Economy. Her latest monograph is Citizen Knowledge. Mar-kets, Experts, and the Infrastructure of Democracy. The current focus of her work are eco-nomic democracy and the philosophy of work.

Montag, 15. Juli, 14:00 Uhr

Prof. Dr. Gregor Wolbring Medizinische Fakultät, Institut für Community Health Sciences, Community Rehabilitation and Disability Studies Program, University of Calgary, Kanada

Disabled people as: academic researchers, community scholars and academic and community research questions

Disabled people face many problems in their lived reality as outlined by the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) that need to be fixed. At the same time new problems that need to be fixed are constantly emerging whereby the old ones are not fixed yet. “Nothing about us without us” reflects the sentiment that disabled people want to be heard on topics that impacts them but think they are often ignored or often are in no position to participate due to their lived reality. Anticipatory governance a concept often used in science and technology governance needs the deployment of anticipatory ad-vocacy by disabled people. Improvement in how research is done and what is researched is one main focus of equity, diversity and inclusion (EDI) and one goal of EDI is to “drive deep-er cultural change within the research ecosystem”.
This presentation will look at disabled people and their allies as knowledge producers, the challenges they face and what has to change through the reality of various actors.

1. The disabled academic
2. The disabled undergraduate and graduate student
3. The disabled community member as community scholar
4. The ally such as students from disability studies programs during their time as students as researcher
5. The ally such as students from disability studies programs after graduation as community scholars.

Dr Gregor Wolbring a lifelong wheelchair user has been trained as a biochemist in Germa-ny (University of Tuebingen, Max Plank Institute for Biophysics, Frankfurt am Main) and the UK (University College London and London Biotechnology Ltd). He worked as a benchwork biochemist at the University of Calgary from 1992-2008. He is now a tenured Full Professor in Community Rehabilitation and Disability Studies in the Cumming School of Medicine, Uni-versity of Calgary and the academic director (disability and accessibility) at the University of Calgary Office for Equity, Diversity and Inclusion.  He is also a member of the Institute for Technology Assessment and Systems Analysis (ITAS), Karlsruhe, Germany and a senior fellow of the Institute for Science, Society and Policy, University of Ottawa, Canada. He re-ceived for example the 1) University of Calgary 2022 Equity, Diversity and Inclusion award; the Bachelor of Health Sciences Research Mentor Award in recognition of making under-graduate students succeed in research (2014, 2016, 2018), the Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medial awarded by the government of Canada in recognition of the benefit of his ac-ademic work to the greater community (2013), and the Council of Canadians with Disabili-ties, National Award (1998). Webpage: https://wolbring.wordpress.com/

The lecture will be online only this time. Please contact Meike Hebich for the Zoom access if you are interested to participate. The language of the event is German.

Monday, 22 January, 14:00 CET

Prof. Dr. Jochen Kolb, Chair of Geochemistry and Economic Geology, Institute of Applied Geosciences, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology

Energy transition and circular economy in a sustainable world need a lot more mining

Europe’s industrial development and the Green Deal chiefly depend on reliable supply of critical raw materials. The recent global situation with political reactions on war, pandemic and economic rivalry shows how fragile many supply chains are. On the other hand, Europe wants to tackle climate change and pollution by actions of the Green Deal with the energy and mobility transitions. Society’s interest in the responsible production of mineral resources is growing. The efforts of many countries and companies to reduce their emissions to net zero result in massive implementation of a wide range of clean energy technologies, many of which rely on critical raw materials.  A typical electric car requires six times the input from high-tech metals as a conventional car. Since 2010, the average amount of metals and minerals needed for a new unit of power generation capacity has increased by 50% as the share of renewables has risen. Thus, the change to a society with reduced environmental and CO2 footprint depends on a secured supply not only of an increasing volume of raw materials but also of a greater variety. Recent as well as historic supply and investment plans for critical raw materials and minerals in Europe fall short of what is needed to support the transition to clean energy technologies. In addition, conventional mining uses a lot of energy and has always an impact on our environment. Comminution alone accounts for more than 50% of a mine’s energy consumption and for at least 3% of total global electricity production. Most of the metals and construction materials that are needed for our daily life still originate from primary resources that are extracted from ore deposits via conventional mining. Despite the relatively high recycling rate for some metals like Fe, Ni, Co and Sn (>50%), import is still indispensable to satisfy the constantly increasing demand. Most of the mines, mills, smelters and refineries, however, are not located in Europe. Still, economic growth on top of energy and mobility transition, and increased resource consumption are positively correlated. Consequently, Europe’s economy and Green Deal largely depend on imported material that often originates from politically and economically unstable countries with low environmental standards. The consequences are unstable supply chains, pollution, increased CO2 footprint and precarious employment situations in the production states. A secured raw materials supply must stand on four pillars: (1) primary raw materials extraction in Europe; (2) recycling; (3) establishing complete value chains in the EU; and (4) secured supply chains from outside Europe. The major challenge is to generate public awareness of the challenges and its acceptance for raw materials industry projects.

Jochen Kolb holds the Chair of Geochemistry and Economic Geology at the Institute of Applied Geosciences, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Germany. He is Dean of Studies for seven geoscience degree programs. He has more than 25 years experience in economic geology research with a strong focus on orogenic gold deposits. He recently started programs on lithium resources in geothermal brines and processing of such brines. After finishing his degree in geology at the Goethe University in Frankfurt, he continued his PhD, Postdoc and Assistant Professorship at RWTH Aachen University, Germany. Before he started in Karlsruhe in 2016, he worked for 10 years as Senior Research Scientist and later as Research Professor at the Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland. Jochen has been Associate Professor at Copenhagen University during this time. Jochen is spokesperson of the topic Georesources at the KIT Climate and Environment Centre. On top of this, he is active in various national and interdisciplinary initiatives related to raw materials, exploration, mining, processing and relationships to societal and economic development.